When Brad Womack joked about finding the love of his life by getting back with his ex-girlfriend after he rejected both of his remaining suitors -- Jenni Croft and DeAnna Pappas -- during the The Bachelor's final eleventh-season Rose Ceremony, there was apparently some truth behind it.

The 34-year-old Austin, TX bar owner was spotted "looking extremely cozy" with ex-girlfriend Laurel Kagay at Las Vegas' Social House restaurant on December 9, In Touch Weekly reported in its December 24 issue.

"Brad and Laurel had dinner with two friends at around 8PM, and it was very clear that it was a double date," a "witness" told In Touch.  "They were gazing at each other, laughing, and sitting very close."

After dinner, the witness told In Touch that Womack and Kagay left the table before entering into the same bathroom together.

"Laurel was giggling and pulled Brad in before closing the door," the witness recounted to In Touch.

Womack and Kagay, the owner of Peach Body Boutique in Westlake, TX, had dated for three years prior to his appearance as The Bachelor's eleventh-season object of affection.  After whittling down 25 bachelorettes during the Fall 2007 installment of the ABC reality dating series, Womack became the first The Bachelor star in the show's history to reject both of his final suitors during the last Rose Ceremony.

Womack's outing with Kagay came only about a week after an The Ellen DeGeneres Show appearance in which Womack had repeated his The Bachelor: After the Final Rose special claims that he hadn't been dating anyone since The Bachelor finished production late this summer.

"I will look you in the eye -- or anybody out there in America in the eye -- and say I haven't grabbed a single cup of coffee with anybody," said Womack during the special.

Womack had also specifically denied rumors that he was back with Kagay during comments published in In Touch's December 10 issue.

"My ex Laurel is amazing, but I'm definitely not back with her," Womack told In Touch.  "I haven't had so much as a cup of coffee with another woman since filming the show."

Included in In Touch's December 24 report is a photo of Womack and Kagay leaving the Social House together.  They presumably didn't have coffee together.