"We're pregnant! I am so excited... We have always dreamed of having a child and we are so happy to finally be making our dreams come true together," Ashley captioned an Instagram photo of the couple holding a sonogram photo of their unborn child at the time.
"Girls seem to be the first born on both [sides] of our families so we can't say we were surprised... All we were really hoping for was a healthy baby though. I don't think either of us really had a preference on the sex of the baby," Anthony told People at the time.
"As the dad, my first thought was, 'Oh man, I'm in trouble!' I know she will have me wrapped around her little finger. Ashley can't wait to do all the girl things that moms do with their daughters and I can't wait to watch them bond."
While Ashley was pregnant, the pair moved from the city streets of Chicago to a home they could call their own in the suburbs.
All three of Married at First Sight's fifth-season couples opted to remain together on "Decision Day" at the end of the extreme experiment; however, Anthony and Ashley are the only one of the three still married today.