The couples couldn't help but question Matt's claims once he and Amber reunited two months after "Decision Day" during Lifetime's September 19 broadcast of Married at First Sight: Couples Couch, which features former MAFS couples offering commentary on encore broadcasts of the show's ninth season.
"I bet he's dreading today," Danielle said of Matt having to see Amber again after the pair mutually decided to get a divorce.
Matt and Amber's problems seemed to begin when Matt disappeared for 24 hours fairly early in the eight-week experiment. When Matt spoke to Married at First Sight expert Dr. Pepper Schwartz about his behavior, Jamie mocked how Matt had claimed it was just "one time, one night."
"But then he did it again," Danielle pointed out.
Matt and Amber had a few good times during their marriage, such as when Matt sang her a song he had written for their one-month anniversary.
FOLLOW REALITY TV WORLD ON THE ALL-NEW GOOGLE NEWS!
Reality TV World is now available on the all-new Google News app and website. Click here to visit our Google News page, and then click FOLLOW to add us as a news source!
But Kristine and Ashley apparently didn't think the song was sweet or genuine.
Kristine laughed out loud at the song, and then Ashley admitted, "This is the worst song ever. You should've left right now, Amber! You should've been, like, 'I'm out!'"
Watching footage back of Amber crying over Matt throughout the eight-week experiment, Jamie said, "This is so awkward; I can't even watch."
"Matt was like, 'Let's just get through [Decision Day] so I can move on," Danielle suggested. "I hope she's with that guy, [Raven], her friend."
Amber told the reunion special's host Kevin Frazier that Matt has everything a woman would want in a husband, recalling how he's artistic, creative, and athletic.
"Whoa, that is NOT everything I want in a husband. I want loyalty, respect, love!" Jamie exclaimed.
"Those are [dumb]," Doug joked with his wife. "As long as you have art and athleticism, you're fine."
After Matt said he didn't know how leaving his wife for the night would affect her, Jamie mocked his comment and repeated it with a laugh.
"He wouldn't know how it would affect her, ahh, it wouldn't take a rocket scientist to figure out she wouldn't be happy you didn't come home and you left your ring at home!" Jamie exclaimed, referencing how Matt stayed out all night without his wedding ring.
"Such an artsy answer," Doug joked.
In terms of Matt getting caught with another woman at a bar, Matt explained that if he sees someone out whom he knows, he's going to talk to that person.
"Bullsh-t!" Ashley yelled.
"He's so tall he can see everybody in the bar," Doug said. "Except for Amber's best friend [Raven]!"
Amber said she was also humiliated at work because a fellow teacher showed her Matt had been texting a friend of hers and asking the woman out while married.
Matt, however, claimed the woman he had been in contact with "just a friend."
"Just a friend?! He's married!" Keith said.
Matt insisted Amber didn't know the girl he left the bar with, but Amber said she did.
"Obviously she knows," Bobby predicted based on the confident expression on Amber's face.
All of the Married at First Sight alums seem to agree getting a divorce was the right decision for Matt and Amber to make on "Decision Day." It appears being cordial with each other will even be a problem for the couple going forward.