However, Caitlin has apparently moved on with Chad, the famous villain from JoJo Fletcher's season of The Bachelorette, who memorably got drunk on Bachelor in Paradise 3 and stormed off the beach yelling, "F-ck you, Chris Harrison!"
Chad, a 31-year-old fitness trainer who currently lives on the West coast, toldLife & Style he has been "seriously" talking to Caitlin, 25, and is "trying to see where that goes."
When Life & Style published the report, Chad provided a link to it on Twitter and added a heart emoji to the post.
Chad said he and Caitlin have been chatting for the past few months after he successfully slid into the realtor's direct messages on Instagram.
However, Caitlin was a little hesitant at first to begin dating Chad due to his public image in Bachelor Nation.
Chad told the magazine Caitlin was "a bit held back," explaining that he's "still the bad guy" in The Bachelor world.
"A lot of the viewers who have seen that show haven't seen the other four shows I've done where I'm actually a pretty good guy... So, I'm trying to see where that goes," said Chad, who has also subsequently appeared on additional reality shows including Famously Single and Celebrity Big Brother U.K.