However, based on a series of Instagram photos recently obtained by Reality Steve spoiler blogger Steve Carbone, it appears Aaron is currently dating a San Diego-based woman whom he began spending time with at least nine months ago.
"It's pretty clear she's making it known on her Instagram that her and Aaron are a thing," Carbone said on the November 10 episode of his podcast.
Carbone even went as far as to call the woman in question Aaron's "new girlfriend."
"And based on some of her IG posts," Carbone wrote in a November 10 blog posting which was released shortly after his podcast, "[it] seems like this is someone who's been around for a while."
On Wednesday, the "Game of Roses" Instagram page posted a video featuring podcast host Chad Kultgen calling Aaron "a f-cking superstar" for "manufacturing" drama with Genevieve out of nothing on Bachelor in Paradise's eighth season.
"Aaron Clancy is one of the best players Paradise has EVER seen. #BachelorInParadise #BachelorNation," read the caption.
Genevieve was clearly offended by the analysis and commented on the posting on Thursday.
"Creating drama from nothing, at someone else's expense who actually has a heart and isn't 'playing a game,' shouldn't be praised," Genevieve wrote. "That's sad."
Genevieve also posted a TikTok video of herself lip syncing the words to a Jersey Shore Season 4 scene in which Samantha "Sammi" Sweetheart broke up with her boyfriend Ronnie Ortiz-Magro after Ronni admitted he had called another girl back home in Long Island while he was vacationing in Italy with Sammi and the rest of Jersey Shore's cast.
Genevieve -- who was only a teenager when the Jersey Shore season originally aired on MTV in 2011 -- mouthed only Sammi's portion of the scene, seemingly calling out Aaron for his alleged analogous "girl back home" behavior on social media.
"It is true. I did call a girl while I was here," Ronnie says in the audio.
"Who?" Sammi asks.
"Just some random girl that I just..." Ronnie responds.
"Hook up with?" Sammi interjects.
"No," Ronnie states.
"Who is it?" Sammi asks.
"Just some girl," Ronnie repeats.
"Look at me in the face," Sammi pushes.
"Just some girl," Ronnie says.
"Who?" Sammi asks. "No, no, no. Tell me a name."
[Bachelor in Paradise Spoiler Warning: The rest of this report spoils what happened between Aaron and Genevieve in Paradise and where their relationship stands now.]
Last week, the woman that Aaron is allegedly dating posted a photo of a vase filled with red and white roses and lilies. She tagged Aaron's Instagram handle along with a red heart emoji, insinuating The Bachelorette alum had bought her the flowers for her birthday and they have a romantic relationship.
The woman also posted several photos from her birthday night out. The celebration apparently included Aaron's Bachelor in Paradise buddies Logan Palmer and Jacob Rapini, and in one image, Aaron was kissing the woman on the cheek.
While it's not a big deal for Aaron to be dating someone new nearly five months after his Bachelor in Paradise stint completed filming, Carbone also found a suspicious picture the woman had posted on Instagram 18 weeks ago.
In the Instagram posting Carbone obtained from July, the woman and Aaron were at the beach together and Aaron had his arm tightly around her as they posed with a group of apparent male and female friends.
"If my math is correct, looks to be right after he got back from BIP filming. 18 weeks ago from now is around beginning of July, and BIP filmed basically all of June," Carbone explained in his blog.
The woman also posted a photo with Aaron in Summer 2021 from when they apparently took a trip to Tulum, Mexico together.
In the photo, the pair seem to be enjoying a private outing at Cenotes Casa Tortuga, where guests can swim in cenote pools. The pair also appear affectionate and couple-like in the Tulum photo, sitting side-by-side in swimsuits with the woman's arm around Aaron and no one else visible in the cenote pool.
"There's nothing that I've found from right before he left for BIP filming," Carbone clarified.
"But I'm just being realistic here. Aaron is no different than a lot of the guys in this franchise. Plenty of them go on the main show and BIP with women back home that are basically put on 'hold,' or they have in the back of their minds if things don't work out."
The spoiler blogger thinks Aaron just wanted to have fun in Mexico and gain more Instagram followers. Carbone believes Aaron "played" Genevieve, used her for roses in Paradise, and was never interested in having a serious relationship with her.
"[It] kind of explains his [hot and cold] behavior with her. One minute he's telling her he's not just falling in love with her, but that he IS in love with her. Then a day later he's fighting with her again," Carbone wrote.
"It just screams to me he knew he had someone back home and was just doing whatever he could to stay on the beach as long as he could."
Bachelor in Paradise continues to air on Monday and Tuesday nights at 8PM ET/PT until its November 22 finale on ABC. While it won't air on ABC until next week, the season's reunion show was already filmed on November 4.