One The Bachelorette fan wrote Saturday on Instagram, "Move on people .. Hannah will choose the perfect guy for her one day it's not Tyler," according toUs Weekly.
"And the crew is boring without her. Her and [Ryan Cameron] and [Matt James] were the best."
Tyler, 27, reportedly quipped in reply, "How many cats do you have?"
Amid the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, Hannah traveled to Tyler's hometown of Jupiter, FL, on March 14 to social distance with Tyler, Tyler's brother Ryan, and a handful of the guys' friends, including Matt, who was cast onClare Crawley's upcoming season of The Bachelorette.
Nicknamed the "Quarantine Crew," the group had released hilarious Instagram and TikTok videos during their time together. They enjoyed the beach, danced, exercised, dressed up in costumes, and pulled pranks on each other while trying to protect themselves and others from the spread of coronavirus.
Another Instagram user reportedly wrote this past weekend, "Tyler probably won't read this, but I'm sorry you definitely have 2 personalities. The dear sweet one on The Bachelor and the one who is acting like a total jerk. Hannah probably couldn't get away from you fast enough."
And Tyler responded, "Looks like we got another cat lady on our hands."
But on Thursday, April 2, Tyler reportedly just called Hannah "a good friend" during a Zoom chat with fans.
Hannah selected Jed Wyatt as the winner of her heart over Tyler on The Bachelorette last year at the Final Rose Ceremony, but the former beauty pageant queen broke up with Jed five weeks after they got engaged because he had lied about having a girlfriend back home in Nashville during filming.
OnThe Bachelorette's live reunion special in late July 2019, Hannah asked Tyler out on a date, which resulted in the pair spending one night together in Los Angeles, CA, in early August.
However, nothing ever came of it because Tyler appeared to set his sights on supermodel Gigi Hadid, and then he moved away from his parents to New York City to pursue modeling.
Tyler and Gigi's romance only lasted a couple of months, and then he had a fling with Kylie Jenner's best friend Anastasia "Stassie" Karanikolaou.