Galloway, a U.S. Army veteran and double amputee, popped the question to his girlfriend Jamie Boyd just as Andrews was interviewing him about his Viennese waltz with pro partner Sharna Burgess. Andrews was caught in the middle of his proposal with nowhere to hide, and she appeared to try to hold back her tears.
However, Us Weeklyclaimed Andrews looked "more than annoyed" because she wanted to wrap up the segment and "was caught on camera rolling her eyes while touching her ear piece."
So what does Andrews have to say about it?
"@usweekly uhhhhh it's called an oh great I'm going to bawl on camera..ugly cry face alert," Andrews tweeted Monday night.
The Fox Sports broadcaster also reiterated the same thing to a follower's comment on Twitter, adding, "It's called emotion..as in, oh my gosh I'm going to loose it right here.."
Andrews had also shared a photo of Galloway's proposal on social media, writing that she loves the couple.
That's not the only thing Andrews has been taking heat for. She also cut short a heartfelt conversation between Bruno Tonioli and Val Chmerkovskiy during last night's show, and one Twitter user called the move "so rude."
"Ahaha producers telling me to wrap! I [heart] Twitter," Andrews tweeted sarcastically in response.
One of the four remaining couples will be sent home during Tuesday night's Dancing with the Stars results show on ABC. The three pairs who survive the cut will compete in next week's twentieth-season finale.