Evan, an erectile dysfunction expert, also has three sons from a previous relationship -- Nathan, Liam and Ensley.
When Carly announced she was pregnant, she took to Instagram and wrote, "Beer Belly, Bella Belly, BABY BELLY!!! We so SO EXCITED to FINALLY announce Bella's little brother or sister will be here in November!!! (If you wonder why I haven't been on social media as much... well, this is why!)"
Evan added at the time on his own Instagram account, "OK, so I think I finally figured out what's causing all these babies. Baby number 473ish coming soon! (Im currently carefully curating this babies Instagram page to be released with ointment line in 2054.)"
Carly and Evan sat onstage with their daughter Bella when Bachelor in Paradise host Chris Harrison said, "So, a little something extra for Bachelor Nation -- you guys have allowed us to do the gender reveal."
RELATED LINK: 'THE BACHELOR' FRANCHISE COUPLES NOW