"Juan Pablo's so smooth. He's a playboy!" one ex-girlfriend told Us Weekly it its latest issue.
"All of his friends set him up with women, but he never settles down. He dates a woman, and then moves on to another one. He's usually seeing someone... Out of Juan and his friends, he dates the most women."
While Galavis, a 32-year-old single dad and former pro soccer player from Venezuela, has said multiple times the worst part of starring on The Bachelor's eighteenth season was hurting people, the ex-girlfriend said Galavis can't help being a heartbreaker.
"Juan Pablo is VERY fickle," she noted.
Another woman who dated Galavis for six months also told Us that Galavis can be "self-centered" at times.
"When you're dating Juan, you're along for HIS ride," the second ex-girlfriend said, adding that Galavis must travel often for his current job as a sports and entertainment consultant although he currently resides in Miami, FL.
"[He] likes a girl who will follow him around."
The first ex-girlfriend shared the same sentiment, telling the magazine that she and Galavis "didn't work out because we just couldn't see each other enough. He goes away a lot. We just fizzled."
Despite the negatives, both of Galavis' former flames had wonderful things to say about him as well. The girls raved about his charm, how he's a gentleman and how he truly puts his four-year-old daughter Camila and family first.
The second ex-girlfriend -- who, again, lasted six months in the relationship -- met Galavis at a sporting event which happened to be a group outing.
"The moment Juan Pablo looked at me, I was into him. He had really kind eyes and a genuine smile," the second ex-girlfriend explained.
The pair reportedly engaged in an afternoon of talking and flirting before they exchanged numbers and parted ways.
"He texted me right away. He said, 'You're beautiful. Can I see you tomorrow?'" she added. "Juan is a total gentleman... He paid for all our dinners. Nothing out-of-this-world expensive, but they were high-end. He ordered wine for us and bought me gifts."
The woman further explained that she and Galavis slept in the same bed on their second date but didn't hook up. She said they ended up having sex for the first time about a month into their relationship.
"We saw each other every week, sometimes twice a week," the second ex-girlfriend recalled. "But he did not mind waiting. He was raised in a house where he was taught respect for women."
The first ex-girlfriend also told Us that "Juan adores his daughter. He talks about every little thing she does... All the women who dated him still really like him. He has a good relationship with all of them."
A third source, who said she only went on several dates withThe Bachelor star in 2011, defended Galavis' dating history.
"Setting Juan up [with women] became a pet project for his friends because he's really looking for a partner," the source said.
Galavis shares Camila with his ex-girlfriend Carla Rodriguez, a Venezuelan-born actress who also currently lives in Miami, FL. The couple dated for a few years but split in 2010. They still reportedly have a great relationship and are supportive of one another.