Rycroft reunited with former boyfriend Ty Strickland after she was dumped by Mesnick. The couple got engaged in June and wed in December.
The 25-year-old Malaney wore $45,000, strapless Monique Lhuillier gown and Neil Lane jewelry and walked down the 200-foot aisle as former American Idol finalist Jason Castro sang "Somewhere Over the Rainbow," People reported. The 33-year-old previously divorced Mesnick wore a dark suit and a black tie for the 15-minute ceremony, which ended with white doves being released into raining skies.
The couple -- who had gotten engaged in October -- exchanged their vows under a driftwood-covered arbor that was decorated with white orchids, pieces of driftwood, and antique butterfly cages, according to People.
Pouring rain interrupted the exchange, according to Us Weekly.
The reception followed indoors in a resort ballroom and was proceeded by Castro singing "That's What I'm Here For" as Mesnick and Malaney left the ceremony, Us Weekly reported.
The couple plans to continue living in Seattle, where they have lived together since Malaney moved there in September, following a tropical honeymoon, according to People.