On her season's After the Final Rose special, a broken-hearted Nick memorably declared to the world that Andi had made love to him, which was a public announcement Andi called "below the belt" since she feels what happens in the bedroom is a personal matter. Andi was furious at Nick at the time, as was her then-fiance.
Andi and Josh, however, called off their engagement and split in January 2015 after eight months together. And Nick eventually came to regret revealing he had sex with Andi on national television, explaining in a variety of interviews that he learned from his mistakes.
About a year after her split from Josh, Andi released a tell-all memoir It's Not Okay in which she opened up about both of her reality TV romances. She detailed an awkward sexual encounter with Nick in the Fantasy Suite and accused Josh of being controlling, temperamental and verbally abusive in their relationship post-show.
While Josh called Andi's book "fiction," Nick confessed on Season 3 of Bachelor in Paradise her memoir was pretty accurate for the most part -- which probably won him some points with his ex.
Although Andi found love on The Bachelor franchise once, she told TMZ that she will never appear on the series again.
"Hell no!" Andi said when asked whether she'd return. "It's worth it, but I had my time. I think America is happy for me to be one and done."