The Season 23 The Bachelor couple revealed they'd love to film a reality show with Cassie's sister Michelle Randolph and the model's boyfriend, actor Gregg Sulkin, during an appearance onUs Weekly's "Watch With Us" podcast.
Michelle and Gregg's transition into reality television would presumably be seamless.
FOLLOW REALITY TV WORLD ON THE ALL-NEW GOOGLE NEWS!
Reality TV World is now available on the all-new Google News app and website. Click here to visit our Google News page, and then click FOLLOW to add us as a news source!
Michelle previously starred in the made-for-TV movie A Snow White Christmas in 2018, and Gregg has starred on Hulu's The Runaways and is also known for his role on Faking It.
"We talked about how there's been no actor and actresses who double dipped like showing behind the scenes of auditioning and having to film his show," Colton explained.
Colton has apparently become great friends with Gregg ever since he and Cassie wrapped filming on The Bachelor and re-entered the real world.
"Gregg's an awesome dude, one of the best human beings. I have a man crush on Gregg. If Michelle ever breaks up with Gregg..." Colton began.
"Are you leaving me for Gregg?" Cassie quipped on the Us podcast.
"Well we'll talk about the possibility of weaving him into the relationship," admitted the former professional football player.
It was Colton's friendship with Gregg that actually helped to spoil the ending of The Bachelor's 23rd season. Before the finale aired earlier this year, the guys were spotted going to the gym together.
"Me and Michelle texted them. We're like, 'What is this?! Seriously guys?!'" Cassie recalled.
"That was some BS!" Colton told the magazine of the spoiler speculation he and Gregg had sparked by being together in public.
"I was like, 'Hey bro you want to hang out?' He's like, 'Yeah cool.' We went to the gym and it's a private property. It's a private gym [and] it's shut down, so we didn't think [anything of it]... I just ignored it I didn't try to play it off."
The most obvious storyline for the potential new spin off would be these two couples enjoying double dates! Cassie and Michelle also seem incredibly close as sisters and supportive of one another.