Amanda is reportedly taking things slow this time around, but Bobby posted a photo on Instagram earlier this week of the couple having fun at Stagecoach Festival together.
"Day 3. Who am I kidding.. my old ass can't hang anymore I'm already home in bed #stagecoach #stagecoach2018," Bobby captioned the image of Amanda cuddling up to his side.
The source told E! News, "They have been dating for two months now. Amanda doesn't know where it's going to go yet because they're still getting to know each other, but so far so good!"
The pair reportedly live "close to each other" in Southern California, and the insider said they met after Bobby "slid into her DM's" on Instagram.
Bobby, who is part of the AVP Pro Beach Volleyball Tour League, has yet to meet Amanda's two daughters, Kinsley and Charlie, from her previous marriage to Nick Buonfiglio.
Not only does Bobby have a passion for volleyball, but his social media suggests he's also a dog lover and thrill seeker who enjoys skiing, boating, shooting, hiking, and listening to country music.
Ironically, two years ago, Bobby was photographed at the Stagecoach Festival with formerThe Bachelor and Bachelor in Paradise contestant Lacy Faddoul, who married and split from franchise alum Marcus Grodd all within one year.
Amanda decided to test her luck on reality TV once more when she returned to Mexico to film Bachelor in Paradise's fourth edition in 2017 -- this time, with a guarded heart and a cautious approach to dating.
Although she sparked a semi-serious romance with Robby, their relationship quickly fell apart thanks to photos that surfaced of Robby appearing to kiss another woman at a concert. Amanda also later claimed Robby cared too much about partying, and she confirmed their breakup in early September of last year.