For her round of overnight Fantasy Suite dates, Rachel offered the room key to all three bachelors in order to get to know them better behind closed doors and off-camera, Life & Style reported.
"She spent the night with all three of them," an insider told the magazine. "She only had a few more days to figure out who to accept a proposal from, and her heart was divided in so many different places."
Rachel reportedly called one of her overnight dates "amazing," said the insider, while she described another as "passionate."
But Rachel's time with one suitor went in a different direction. The insider told Life & Style that the guy "felt more like a really good friend" to Rachel rather than a potential fiance and future husband, so she opted to send him home in third place.
Rachel's time in the Fantasy Suites with her three men was reportedly sexy yet also very practical, as the lawyer side of her came out.
"Rachel said, 'I need to get down to the serious stuff in the Fantasy Suites,' and that's exactly what she did," recalled the insider.
"She asked about religion, whether they'd move to LA, where she wants to live. She asked whether they wanted kids and how many, and if they wanted to send them to public or private schools."
Not only did Rachel allegedly ask the guys about their credit scores, the insider added, "She also asked them, 'How much [money] do you make?'"
Heading into the Final Rose Ceremony, Rachel was reportedly torn between the two suitors still in the running for her heart.
"It was an agonizing decision," a source told Life & Style. "In the end, it was one of the toughest decisions a Bachelorette has ever had to make. She decided to go with her heart and hopes she made the right choice."