In addition to Carly and her husband Evan Bass from Season 3 of Bachelor in Paradise, the tight-knit group included Wells and Danielle -- whose friendship turned into something romantic during Tuesday night's episode -- as well as Derek Peth and Taylor Nolan, who have the strongest and deepest relationship on Paradise so far this season.
"We love love!!!" Carly, 31, captioned the cute group photo. "Here's to hoping it works out for everyone like it did for us!!!"
Since Carly wrote that she hopes "it works out for everyone," she's also suggesting that each pair is still romantically involved.
Although Wells, a radio deejay, and Danielle, a neonatal nurse, went on a date about four years ago, the couple became the best of friends since they both currently reside in Tennessee. The individuals had nothing but positive things to say about each other in the latest episodes of Bachelor in Paradise.
Danielle traveled to Mexico in the hope of finding love, while Wells took on the role of bartender with the understanding he's unable to date women on the show.
However, Wells and Danielle's friendship took a turn when Danielle failed to hit if off with any of the men in Paradise and realized Wells would be "totally dateable." Meanwhile, Wells was shown gushing to his friends about how Danielle is beautiful and kind, too good for him, and way out of his league.
Things came to a head when Danielle decided to depart Playa Escondida for a charity trip to Africa, and when Wells walked the bachelorette to her car, he said, "If anyone deserved to find someone here, it was you." And then Wells kissed her.
Danielle, pleasantly surprised by Wells' courageous gesture, didn't expect the kiss at all, but she gushed about how much she liked it on Tuesday night's Bachelor in Paradiseepisode.
"I can't believe that just happened," Danielle told the cameras in her final words. "I've thought about kissing Wells before. He's a good kisser. Wells is a good kisser. I'm really glad I ended Paradise with a good kiss. Maybe he's been under my nose this whole time. We'll have some things to talk about when I get back."
Sparks flew for Taylor and Derek almost immediately in Paradise. They were only focused on each other after meeting and seemed pretty inseparable at the resort ever since. The pair also shows so much affection for each other on the season that cast members tease them about being in love already.