When sizing up the bachelorettes in the running for Arie's heart following the Season 22 premiere, Jimmy Kimmel made his typical Final 4 predictions on Jimmy Kimmel Live! with the Bachelor sitting right next to him.
While Arie insisted he has a pretty good "poker face" and proved that to be true as Jimmy guessed which girls make it to the end, the pro racing driver appeared to have a little slip.
Jimmy predicted Chelsea Roy will be among Arie's last four bachelorettes standing, telling the tight-lipped Bachelor, "Chelsea, you gave her the First Impression Rose, she's very attractive, she's aggressive, she's also clearly going to be the villain, so you need to keep her around for a while."
Jimmy added, "You won't pick her, you'll just keep giving her roses, though, so she can antagonize everyone else in the house."
Despite trying not to give Jimmy a reaction, at this point, Arie shook his head "no," and the audience could be heard gasping in response.
"I think we learned something there," Jimmy pointed out, as everyone laughed, including Arie.
Jimmy then noted he believes Becca K. will be the girl who steals Arie's heart and receives his final rose -- and maybe an engagement ring.
"Despite a weird start, making you get down on one knee, you liked her, she seemed the most kind of normal, there were no red flags, you seemed into her... and you also gave her the first rose at the Rose Ceremony, which means she's probably the name you remembered right off the bat. I believe you will pick Becca K.!" Jimmy said.
Arie shrugged his shoulders and didn't give anything else away.
Also during his Tuesday appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, Arie admitted that the show has affected his career in real estate, but not in a positive way.
"It's a little awkward actually," Arie said, telling the story of a potential client recognizing him at an open house and turning the conversation away from purchasing a house and onto The Bachelor.
Arie also revealed of a different situation, "I drove somebody around, and we looked at houses and then I realized, 'She's not buying a house. She just wanted to hang out.' So I think this might be creating a problem for me."