The Bachelorette star accepted a marriage proposal from one of her Final 2 bachelors when the sixth season's last Rose Ceremony filmed earlier this year and is currently planning for a West Coast wedding that will take place early next year, Us Weekly reported in its July 12 issue.
"She's already thinking about the details," a source told the magazine.
"They'd be perfect together," a source told Us. "He's athletic and she's a tomboy. The scene where they threw a baseball around is so Ali."
In addition, Us speculated that Fedotowsky and Martinez might have known each other prior to meeting on The Bachelorette -- as she graduated from Mount Greylock Regional High School in Williamstown, MA in 2002 and he spent that summer playing baseball just a town away for the North Adams Steeple Cats.
Fedotowsky was one of Jake Pavelka's The Bachelor: On the Wings of Love bachelorettes before she landed The Bachelorette's starring role, and a source told Us that she and ex-boyfriend Patrick Hammon "were hooking up" in between filming for the shows.
"But neither wanted to be in a relationship," the source told Us.
Another source told Us that Fedotowsky and Hammon's reunion was "just for a short-term period" because "she's kind of boy crazy" and reiterated she was "officially single" when The Bachelorette started filming in early March.
"She did the show because she was ready to settle down and get married," the source told Us.