Dakota Mortensen has filed a lawsuit against Hulu and two production companies behind The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, alleging the reality show falsely portrayed him as an abusive partner amid his tumultuous relationship with ex-girlfriend Taylor Frankie Paul.

ADVERTISEMENT


Dakota, 33, is suing Hulu, Jeff Jenkins Productions and Ludwig Productions over his portrayal on Seasons 3, 4 and 5 of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, according to court documents obtained by E! News.

The reality TV star claimed the series depicted him "to millions of viewers as a domestic abuser," as well as a man who allegedly retaliated against Taylor by contacting Child Protective Services and repeatedly cheated on her.

Dakota alleged the show's producers deliberately manipulated footage and manufactured storylines to make him look bad, even after they had allegedly been informed that certain accusations against him weren't true.

According to the lawsuit, the storylines were "assembled from staged events and from the deliberate deletion of footage that contradicted the storyline, and published after the producers had been informed by Mortensen and by others, that the allegations were false."

ADVERTISEMENT


Dakota specifically claimed Taylor physically attacked him with a pizza box while they were filming the show's fifth season, but producers allegedly chose not to include the incident in the final episodes.

Dakota alleged cameras captured the altercation and that he requested the footage be shown to viewers, but his request was apparently ignored.

"The knowingly false portrayal of Mortensen as the abuser in the relationship continued uninterrupted," the lawsuit stated, "while the only footage of physical aggression between the two, aggression by Paul against Mortensen, was intentionally withheld from viewers to promote a false narrative."

Dakota is seeking compensatory damages and additional damages in his lawsuit.

Dakota and Taylor, who welcomed their son Ever True in March 2024, have been embroiled in a contentious custody battle and legal dispute for much of this year.


ADVERTISEMENT


In February, two Utah police departments launched separate domestic violence investigations into alleged altercations between Taylor and Dakota, and allegations were reportedly made in both directions.

On March 19, a video of a 2023 altercation leaked and showed Taylor punching, kicking and throwing metal barstools at Dakota. Taylor's daughter Indy was present and could be heard crying in the background. (Taylor welcomed Indy and son Ocean with her ex-husband Tate Paul).

ABC announced its decision to cancel Taylor's season of The Bachelorette that same day, just three days before Season 22 was scheduled to premiere. (Spoilers for the season have since been leaked and confirmed on Mormon Wives).

Dakota subsequently filed for a protective order against Taylor and was granted temporary custody of Ever.

Taylor filed her own request for a protective order against Dakota on April 7, alleging he had engaged in a "pattern of abusive conduct and coercive control" throughout their on-again, off-again relationship.

ADVERTISEMENT


Taylor claimed Dakota had physically abused her on multiple occasions and submitted photographs of alleged injuries and screenshots of text messages as evidence.

A spokesperson for Taylor previously claimed the MomTok co-creator had silently endured years of physical and mental abuse, as well as threats of retaliation.

Dakota, meanwhile, previously described the situation as "deeply upsetting" in a March statement to E! News.

"I am focusing on our son and his safety," Dakota said at the time, "and hope that Taylor will do the same."

Taylor was initially limited to supervised visitation with Ever, but a Utah court commissioner granted her unsupervised parenting time in June.


ADVERTISEMENT


The former couple were also granted mutual protective orders at an April 30 court hearing.

The Salt Lake County District Attorney's Office announced on April 14 that Taylor would not face criminal charges following the two domestic violence investigations.

Prosecutors explained that some of the alleged incidents occurred more than two years earlier and therefore fell outside the statute of limitations.

Other allegations reportedly did not rise to the level of criminal offenses or lacked sufficient evidence or specificity to support charges.

The district attorney's office, however, indicated that it would reconsider the cases if additional evidence emerged.


Taylor previously pleaded guilty to aggravated assault in August 2023 following her arrest earlier that year, when she was charged with multiple offenses stemming from a domestic dispute with Dakota.

Her plea agreement resulted in the dismissal of four other charges, and she was sentenced to 36 months of probation.

Amid Taylor and Dakota's legal troubles, Hulu temporarily suspended production on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' fifth season in March.

Filming subsequently resumed, although Taylor's involvement in the season was reportedly limited. She also said she won't be returning for the show's sixth season.

Dakota's new lawsuit adds another legal dispute to the former couple's already complicated history, with Dakota now challenging how their relationship and allegations of abuse were presented to viewers.













About The Author: Elizabeth Kwiatkowski
Elizabeth Kwiatkowski is Associate Editor of Reality TV World and has been covering the reality TV genre for more than a decade.